New Provinces in Pakistan: Can Administrative Restructuring Deliver Better Governance?

The debate over creating new provinces in Pakistan has once again entered the national conversation. Recent calls for additional provinces or administrative units have revived an old question: Can a smaller and more decentralised administrative structure make Pakistan more prosperous, accountable and governable? The debate is significant because Pakistan’s problems are no longer limited to political disagreements. They involve weak institutions, uneven development, unemployment, poor public-service delivery, educational disparities, healthcare deficiencies and growing pressure on already overstretched urban centres. Recent proposals have included dividing Punjab into three units and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa into two, although there is considerable disagreement over the boundaries and political implications of any such restructuring.

The creation of new provinces, however, should not be treated as a magical solution. A new map cannot automatically produce better governance. The real question is whether administrative restructuring can bring decision-making, resources and accountability closer to citizens.

Maleeha Lodhi’s Pakistan: Beyond the Crisis State provides an important starting point. The book examines Pakistan’s political, economic, social and institutional challenges while also highlighting possibilities for moving beyond a perpetual crisis mentality. One of its particularly relevant arguments concerns decentralisation and local government. The book notes that development decisions made closer to communities can produce better resource allocation and that provincial governments should focus more on policy, standards, monitoring and accountability while devolving service delivery to lower levels.

This raises an important distinction: new provinces and local governments are not the same thing. If Pakistan creates additional provinces but continues to concentrate administrative authority in provincial capitals, the fundamental problem may remain unchanged. A smaller province could simply reproduce the same centralisation that currently exists at the provincial level.

Ishrat Husain’s Governing the Ungovernable strengthens this argument. Husain identifies the decay of governance institutions as a major explanation for Pakistan’s economic slowdown and advocates selective and incremental restructuring of institutions concerned with accountability, transparency, security, economic growth and equity. His analysis gives considerable importance to federal, provincial and local government structures.

Therefore, if new provinces are created, they should be designed around institutional performance rather than political convenience.

Consider education. Pakistan’s large provinces contain enormous differences in population, geography and educational needs. A remote district and a rapidly expanding metropolitan centre cannot necessarily be governed effectively through identical administrative priorities. Smaller provinces could potentially develop education policies according to regional needs, improve monitoring of schools and make provincial education departments more accessible. But this would work only if schools, teachers, examination systems and education budgets are properly monitored and insulated from political interference.

The same applies to healthcare. Smaller administrative units could make it easier to identify shortages of doctors, medicines, hospitals and emergency services and respond to them more quickly. Provincial health authorities could become more directly accountable to their populations. Yet again, restructuring without professional management, financial autonomy and transparent performance measurement would merely create additional offices and bureaucracies.

Economic development may offer the strongest argument for carefully designed provinces. Pakistan’s economic potential is unevenly distributed. Different regions possess different agricultural, industrial, mineral, tourism, technological and geographical advantages. Smaller provinces could formulate development strategies around their own economic strengths instead of relying excessively on decisions made in distant provincial capitals. They could compete constructively to attract investment, improve infrastructure and develop human capital.

However, new provinces would also create additional administrative expenditures: new assemblies, secretariats, ministries, departments and bureaucratic structures. At a time when Pakistan is already struggling with fiscal constraints, duplication of institutions could become an additional burden. The objective should therefore not be more governments, but better government.

This is where Lodhi’s Pakistan: The Search for Stability becomes particularly relevant. Published in 2024, the book describes Pakistan as facing a multidimensional “polycrisis” involving political, constitutional, economic, security, demographic and ecological pressures. It argues that decades of poor governance and short-term crisis management have prevented the country from addressing structural problems through a long-term vision.

The lesson for the provinces debate is clear: Pakistan cannot afford another reform driven primarily by short-term political calculations. Any restructuring should emerge from a national consensus and be supported by a clear economic, administrative and constitutional framework.

Most importantly, new provinces should be accompanied by genuine local government empowerment. Husain’s work on decentralisation is especially instructive here. His analysis of the 2001 local government system highlights the transfer of functions such as education, health, water supply, roads and agriculture to district governments, while also identifying weaknesses in fiscal and institutional arrangements. In his later work, Husain has argued for devolving school education up to matriculation, primary and secondary healthcare up to district hospitals, water and sanitation, roads, social welfare and other functions to local governments.

Thus, the real reform should perhaps follow a three-tier principle: the federation should concentrate on national responsibilities; provinces should formulate regional policies and standards; and empowered local governments should deliver most basic public services.

Accountability must accompany this devolution. Every additional province should have measurable targets for education, healthcare, employment, investment, tax collection, infrastructure and public-service delivery. Provincial and local officials should be answerable not merely to political leaders but also to citizens through transparent audits, performance indicators, accessible information and effective institutions of justice.

The debate over new provinces, therefore, should not become a debate about which region receives a new capital or which political group gains influence. It should be a debate about how Pakistan can govern itself better.

Pakistan does need administrative reform. But the ultimate objective should not be the multiplication of provinces; it should be the multiplication of opportunities, accountability, efficiency and access to public services.

If new provinces bring government closer to citizens, encourage balanced economic development, strengthen education and healthcare, improve institutional accountability and empower local governments, they could become an important instrument of national progress. If they merely redraw boundaries while preserving the same centralised political and bureaucratic culture, Pakistan will have changed its map without changing its governance.

The challenge, therefore, is not simply to create new provinces. The challenge is to create a new culture of governance. Pakistan’s future requires institutions that serve citizens rather than institutions that merely administer them. Administrative restructuring can be part of that transformation, but only when it is accompanied by fiscal responsibility, democratic participation, professional administration, empowered local governments and a long-term national vision.

 

References

  1. Lodhi, Maleeha, ed. Pakistan: Beyond the Crisis State. Oxford University Press.
  2. Lodhi, Maleeha, ed. Pakistan: The Search for Stability. Hurst/Oxford University Press, 2024.
  3. Husain, Ishrat. Governing the Ungovernable: Institutional Reforms for Democratic Governance. Oxford University Press, 2018.
  4. Husain, Ishrat. “Governance for Local Government” series, The News, 2023.
  5. Recent reporting on the 2026 debate over additional provinces and administrative units in Pakistan.

Advertisement

The writer is a Master’s graduate in English Linguistics from Foundation University Islamabad and currently serves as a contractual Lecturer at the Federal Urdu University of Arts, Science and Technology (FUUAST), Islamabad. With over six years of teaching experience, his academic career reflects a strong commitment to linguistic inquiry, critical pedagogy, and discourse-oriented research. His scholarly expertise lies in Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) and Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL), through which he critically examines how language constructs power relations, identity formation, and ideological frameworks in social, political, and institutional contexts. His research particularly focuses on the discursive construction of “Us versus Them” narratives and their role in sustaining dominance and exclusion within texts and practices. He has published several research articles in the area of discourse analysis, contributing to contemporary debates on how language operates as a tool of social control and meaning-making. His work reflects both theoretical depth and practical relevance, bridging linguistic theory with real-world discourse practices. His academic publications and research contributions are accessible via Google Scholar under the name Zohaib ur Rehman.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *